Talking Shop On Email Marketing

Vanessa Betance is our email marketing specialist at the Bureau. With over 15 years of experience spanning large organizations to small businesses, she’s led email campaigns for McDonald’s, Proctor and Gamble and other Fortune 500 organizations.

We talked to Vanessa about email marketing strategies and best practices regardless of the industry or the size of the organization.

Q: Let’s say I just launched a landscaping architectural business and have zero customers. Where do I even begin with email marketing?

A: If you’re starting a local business from scratch, email marketing isn’t just a nice-to-have, it’s one of your most efficient tools to build trust, educate your community, and stay top of mind until they’re ready to book.

Start with something practical and hyper-relevant, like a free guide: “5 Yard Mistakes Chicago Homeowners Make (and How to Fix Them Fast).” This attracts homeowners in your area, builds your list with the right people, and those who are likely to need you soon.

From there, a simple automated welcome sequence (even 2–3 emails) can:

  • Introduce you and your values
  • Share a seasonal tip or quick win
  • Offer a free estimate or design consult.

Local businesses thrive on trust. Email gives you a consistent way to educate, show your expertise, and create that “I feel like I know you” effect before they ever pick up the phone.

Q: What if I offer an online service that isn’t local? How would that email strategy shift?

A: When your service is entirely online, your email strategy has to work harder because your audience is bigger, the competition is wider, and trust has to be built without proximity.
Instead of relying on location, your emails need to focus on transformation.

That means:

  • Offering a niche-specific lead magnet that solves a real pain point,
    (e.g., “3 Steps to Launch Your Product Without Tech Headaches”).
  • Using email automation to introduce your process, your approach, and your proof.
  • Building an ongoing nurture sequence that positions you as the expert in your lane.

Your welcome sequence is less “here’s who we are” and more “here’s what we help you
become.”

Online, email isn’t just a touchpoint, it’s your conversion engine. It builds credibility, demonstrates your value, and moves people from “curious” to “client/customer.

Q: How do you grow a list full of qualified audiences?

A: Lead with value, not volume.

A qualified list starts with an intentional opt-in like a free resource, quiz, or guide that directly speaks to the needs of your best-fit customer. If it’s too generic, you’ll get unengaged subscribers. But if it’s specific and helpful, you’ll attract people who are already primed for what you offer.

We also like using short forms to segment subscribers right from the start.

For example: “Which best describes you?” or “What’s your biggest challenge right now?” That way, every email that follows feels more personalized and more likely to convert.

Q: How do automated email campaigns help businesses reach specific goals?

A: Think of them as your behind-the-scenes sales team minus the overhead. Automation helps you meet people where they are in the buying journey:

  • New subscriber – Send a welcome series.
  • Browsed but didn’t buy – Send a reminder.
  • Just purchased – Send timed onboarding or upsell emails.
  • Haven’t engaged in a while – Send a reactivation sequence.

The beauty of automation is that it saves time and increases conversions because the message is timely, relevant, and consistent. Set it up once, and it keeps working for you.

Q: What are the key metrics to track with email marketing?

A: Metrics tell the story behind what’s working and what’s not. Here’s what I look at most:

  • Open rate – Are people interested in what you’re sending?
  • Click-through rate – Is the content compelling and actionable?
  • Conversion rate – Are people taking the next step?
  • Unsubscribes – Is the messaging aligned with the audience?

But context is key. It’s not just about “more opens” – it’s about whether your emails are helping you build trust, drive engagement, and support your business goals.

Q: How do you get people to actually open your emails?

A: Your subject line is the first impression so it’s important to make it count.

Great subject lines are clear, curiosity-driven, and relevant. I avoid hype and gimmicks. Instead, I lean into clarity and value. For example:

  • “How to prep your space for winter (even if you hate yardwork).”
  • “Is your website doing its job?”
  • “Before you launch – read this”

Also: Make sure your “from” name is recognizable. People open emails from people they trust.

Q: How do you encourage people to click the call-to-action buttons and visit the website?

A: First, make sure the CTA actually helps the reader, don’t just promote your business goals. Instead of “Book a call,” try: “Get a custom quote in 2 clicks.”

Or instead of “Visit our website,” say: “Explore the design packages built for growing brands.”

The CTA should feel like the next logical step, not a leap. And visually? Keep it clean, clear, and clickable. One main CTA per email is usually enough.

Q: What are re-marketing and re-engagement emails used for?

A: These emails are your chance to follow up with purpose.

Re-marketing emails go to people who showed interest but didn’t convert. Think: “Still thinking it over?” or “You left this in your cart.”

Re-engagement emails are for subscribers who’ve gone quiet. The tone here is warm and curious…something like: “Still want branding tips in your inbox?” or “Tell us what you want more of.”

Both types are about rekindling interest without being pushy. Done right, they can turn maybes into yeses and give you insight into what your audience really wants.

Q: How do you wake up cold subscribers?

A: Cold subscribers don’t need pressure…they need relevance. I usually recommend a simple 2–3 email reactivation series that:

  1. Acknowledges the gap (“We haven’t talked in a while…”).
  2. Offers fresh value (“Here’s a new free resource to help you with X”).
  3. Asks them to re-confirm interest or update their preferences.

Sometimes people just need a reminder of why they signed up.

And if they’re no longer the right fit? That’s okay too. A clean list performs better, every time.